Google, Jeeves, Yahoo: How are they doing?

Even though most people use Google these days, its search results aren’t much different from what you get at other search engines, a study found. The study, conducted by San Mateo, Calif.-based market research firm Vividence, surveyed and monitored 2,000 people as they used Google, Ask Jeeves, Lycos, Microsoft’s MSN, and Yahoo, CNET reports. It found, for example, that in a search for the leading cause of death for people between 25 and 34, Google users found what they were looking for 55% of the time and people using its competitors reported success rates of between 52% and 54%. “The company found that Google clearly remains consumers’ favorite, largely because of the search engine’s less-cluttered interface. In fact, Vividence said almost 90% of Google users reported having a ‘strongly positive experience’.” Those figures were 68% at Yahoo, 50% at Ask Jeeves, 48% for Lycos, and 41% for MSN. And why do we need to know this? Well, Wellesley College found in a study last year that fewer than 2% of students surveyed used non-Internet sources in research they were asked to do. The study “also revealed the extraordinary confidence students have in search engines,” its authors, two Wellesley professors said. For more on this, see “Critical thinking: Kids’ best research (and online-safety) tool” in my 5/30/03 issue.